PH&N Dividend Income Fund
The Phillips, Hager & North Dividend Income
Fund has come through the turmoil of the three
years ended September 30th comparatively well,
having gained an average of 14.3% annually over
that period. This represents excellent performance
compared to the 5.5% average annual loss of the
S&P/TSX60. During the first nine months of the
year, the fund lost 13.8% of its value due to low
weightings in the energy, gold, and consumer
staples sectors. However, this is still far better
than the 22% loss experienced by the index.
The fund is managed by a team of ten
portfolio managers led by Dale Harrison. On
average, the fund's managers have been with
PH&N for about ten years. These managers
usually invest in dividend paying common stocks
of mature companies which are selected using a
self-described 'quality growth' style based on
company profitability, financial strength, and
earnings growth. This is essentially a GARP or
growth at a reasonable price style with the
emphasis on growth. The fund's low portfolio
turnover is a testament to the fund's long-term
focus.
Although preferred shares are explicitly
mentioned in the fund's charter as potential
investments, they have not been in favor with the
fund's management for some time. Mr. Harrison
and his colleagues feel that the potential for growth
and capital appreciation is much more attractive
for common shares. As a result, the current
portfolio includes no preferred shares. Likewise,
the fund holds no bonds other than short-term
notes.
At the end of the third quarter, the fund's
portfolio included 37 stocks. Of these, only
CISCO systems did not pay a dividend, and six
reported negative earnings. Taken as an aggregate,
the fund's portfolio is somewhat expensive. It's
earnings yield of 5.1% is higher than the 2%
offered by the S&P/TSX60 index and represents
good relative value. The portfolio's dividend yield
of 2.7% is higher than the yield of the index (about
2.3%), but it is not as high as it could be which
demonstrates a preference for dividend growth.
From a value perspective, the portfolio's price/book
ratio of 1.7 is also a bit on the high side, but on par
with the index.
Canadian equities make up 83.2% of the
portfolio's total assets, while 16.3% is invested in
U.S. equities; the fund's cash position is modest at
0.5% of total assets, up from 0.1% at the end of the
previous quarter. Financial stocks represent 45.6%
of the portfolio, down from 47.3% at the end of the
second quarter. Financials are followed by
industrials and telecommunications which make up
12.8% and 11.7%, respectively, of the fund's
holdings. The fund's telecommunications exposure
is up from 9.8%, while industrials are down from
13%. During the third quarter the fund was active
and reduced its total number of holdings from 40 to
37. Positions in Encana, Fording, Toromont,
Canadian Pacific Railways, and Fairmont Hotels
and Resorts were eliminated. At the same time
new positions in Alcan and George Weston Ltd.
were added, and an existing position in CP Ships
was substantially increased.
With an average annual return of 12.3%
over the past 15 years, the PH&N Dividend Income
fund is first among Canadian dividend funds over
the long term. Although the $25,000 minimum
investment likely puts the fund beyond the reach of
smaller investors, a low 1.16% MER for this kind
of performance is a bargain for those with the
means. Excellent long-term performance and an
attractive MER makes this fund our top pick for
frugal investors seeking growing dividend income.
FF: Q3 2002
| |
|